Older house on a wooded hillside above a fieldstone retaining wall in autumn

Mine Subsidence Insurance in PA: What Buyers Around Scranton Should Know

Insurance for What’s Under the House

Mine subsidence insurance is a state program, run by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, that pays for damage when old underground coal or clay mines collapse beneath a building. Regular homeowners insurance usually doesn’t cover it. As of November 2026, DEP says $150,000 of coverage on a home costs $41.25 a year, and you can check any address on the state’s free risk map.

If you’re buying anywhere from Scranton to Wilkes-Barre, check the address before you close. It takes a few minutes and the coverage costs less than a tank of gas a month.

Why This Matters in Our Valley

The towns between Scranton and Wilkes-Barre were built on coal. The U.S. Geological Survey describes the Northern Anthracite coal basin as a trough about 62 miles long and about 5 miles wide running northeast across this corner of the state, with its deepest coal near Wilkes-Barre and mining regions around Nanticoke, Kingston, Pittston and Scranton. For generations, miners took coal out from under the same ground where people built houses.

Most of those mines closed long ago. DEP’s own explanation is blunt: abandoned mines can collapse decades after mining ends, and it’s hard to predict if or when one will fail. Most collapses happen where the coal was less than 50 feet below the surface.

DEP estimates more than one million structures in Pennsylvania could be damaged by mine subsidence. At the end of state fiscal year 2024, only 62,426 of them were insured. That’s about 6% of the buildings at risk.

What It Covers, and What It Doesn’t

DEP defines mine subsidence as movement of the ground surface caused by the collapse of underground coal or clay mines. It shows up two ways: a sudden hole (what most people call a sinkhole), or a slow sag in the ground called a trough, which can crack foundations and rack walls.

Covered:

  • Damage to the insured building, whether complete or under construction.
  • Ground movement from a mine water blowout, the sudden release of water from a flooded mine.
  • Appurtenances: fences, retaining walls, patios, walks, driveways and in-ground pools. These are limited to 10% of your coverage amount and only paid if the house itself is damaged in the same event.
  • Incidental costs like temporary housing, higher utility bills and securing the property. Policies written or renewed after December 11, 2013 pay between $600 and $7,000 for these, depending on the loss. That money comes out of your coverage amount, not on top of it.

Not covered:

  • Your belongings. The policy covers the building and its appurtenances only.
  • A detached garage, unless it has its own policy. Each building needs its own.
  • Sinkholes caused by limestone weathering. Those aren’t mine subsidence.

Claims are investigated by DEP and paid on the actual cost to repair or replace, up to your coverage or the replacement cost of the building, whichever is less.

Mine Subsidence Insurance on pa.gov

What It Costs

According to DEP, read November 13, 2026:

CoverageCost
Residential rateAbout 27 cents per $1,000 of coverage per year
$150,000 of coverage on a home$41.25 a year
Coverage available$5,000 to $1,000,000
Senior discount10% off on your primary residence if you’re 65 or older by the premium due date

DEP suggests insuring your home for its replacement value plus 20%, which leaves room for appurtenances and incidental costs. Policies run one year and renew annually. If your lender escrows insurance, forward the MSI bill to your lender. The program doesn’t bill lenders directly.

Use DEP’s premium calculator for your own number. If you want to see what it adds to a monthly payment, the mortgage calculator has a line for it.

How to Check a House Before You Buy

  1. Look up the address on the MSI Risk map. Enter the address, coordinates or municipality on DEP’s MSI Risk map. It shows the mining status under the site and whether DEP recommends coverage.
  2. Ask for site-specific records if you want more. DEP keeps a repository of underground mine maps. You can request information about mining at a specific location through the MSI Site-Specific Request Form linked from the DEP program page.
  3. Read the house, too. The damage DEP shows in its own photos looks like cracked brick, cracked foundations and porch columns pulling away from the house. Cracks like that can come from mine subsidence. They can also come from ordinary settling, frost, poor drainage or old construction. DEP’s own list of things that get mistaken for mine subsidence includes settlement, landslides, soil swelling and shrinking, freezing and thawing, erosion, poor construction and plain structural wear. A good home inspector, and sometimes a structural engineer, can tell you which you’re looking at. See older home inspections.
  4. Ask the seller. Has there been a claim on this house? Is there a policy in place now? Has any structural repair been done?

When to Apply

DEP’s guidance for buyers is to apply when you have a signed agreement to buy, or when you apply for your mortgage. Coverage starts at closing, as long as any required inspection doesn’t turn up damage that has to be dealt with first.

A few practical points from the program’s FAQs:

  • Some homes need an inspection first. If the building sits in an area with a record of past or recent problems, a fund representative will contact you to inspect before a policy is issued. That’s one more reason to apply early, not the week of closing.
  • Damaged houses can sometimes still be insured. The damage either has to be repaired first or have a repair estimate on file, and that cost is excluded from any later claim. No policy is issued while a building is actively being damaged.
  • You can apply online with a credit or debit card, through an insurance agent with Pennsylvania property authority, or by calling the MSI help desk at 1-(800) 922-1678 for a paper application.

Do You Really Need It?

Honest answer: probably nothing will happen. DEP’s own report says the historical probability of a subsidence event is low. The same report says the cost to repair the damage when it does happen is often high, and that most of those costs are paid by owners who didn’t have coverage.

DEP’s surveys found that most people in mining regions who skip the coverage do it because they think the risk is small. They’re usually right. The ones who aren’t can lose a house. At a few dollars a month, if the map says your address is undermined, I’d buy it.

The fund has been around since 1961 and, per DEP, had paid more than $46 million in claims by the end of state fiscal year 2023 to 2024.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need mine subsidence insurance in Scranton or Wilkes-Barre?

The state doesn’t make you buy it, but if DEP’s MSI Risk map shows the address over or near old mine workings, it’s worth having. Homeowners insurance usually excludes mine subsidence. Much of the valley from Nanticoke through Wilkes-Barre, Pittston and Scranton sits on the Northern Anthracite coal basin, so check every address.

How much does mine subsidence insurance cost in PA?

As of November 2026, DEP says residential coverage costs about 27 cents per $1,000 a year, and $150,000 of coverage costs $41.25 a year. Homeowners 65 and older get 10% off on their primary residence. Use DEP’s online premium calculator for an exact figure.

Does mine subsidence insurance cover sinkholes?

It covers holes and troughs caused by the collapse of underground coal or clay mines, and ground movement from a mine water blowout. It does not cover sinkholes from limestone weathering. It covers the building and some appurtenances, not your belongings.

When should I apply if I'm buying a house?

When you have a signed agreement of sale or when you apply for your mortgage. Coverage takes effect at closing, provided any inspection DEP requires doesn’t find damage that needs to be addressed. Some areas require an inspection, so don’t leave it to the last week.

Is my detached garage covered?

No. Each building needs its own mine subsidence policy, so a detached garage needs a separate one. DEP’s 10% senior discount also applies to policies on outbuildings at a primary residence.

Buying Over Old Mines

It’s part of buying a house here, like snow tires. When we find a house you like, I’ll check the address on the MSI map with you before you write the offer, and we’ll build the insurance into your timeline so it’s in place at closing.

Ready to Talk?

Call or text me at (570) 905-4300, or send me a note. More on buying here: the first-time buyer guide, and town pages for Scranton, Taylor and Old Forge. All buyer tools are on the Buy page.