Tray of square cut red and white pizza on a wooden table by a window, paper plates and sodas

Old Forge, PA Real Estate: Homes Sold, Pizza and Daily Life

Old Forge at a Glance

Old Forge is a small Lackawanna County borough on the Lackawanna River, between Taylor and the Luzerne County line, and it had one of the fastest housing markets of the ten towns I work in. Homes in Old Forge sold for a median of about $222K in the three months through October 2026, up 10.5% from a year earlier, and the typical home spent about 13 days on the market (Redfin). It’s also known as the Pizza Capital of the World, and around here nobody argues.

What Homes Sold For in Old Forge

MeasureOld ForgeA year earlier
Median sale price (3 months through October 2026)$222Kup 10.5%
Days on market (October 2026)1320
Homes sold (October 2026)1927
Sale price as a share of list price (October 2026)101.5%100.1%
Homes that sold above list price (October 2026)42%33%

Source: Redfin, Old Forge housing market, read November 13, 2026.

Old Forge is a seller’s market right now. The typical home sold for a little more than its asking price in October, and four in ten went over. Redfin scored Old Forge 84 out of 100 for competitiveness, “very competitive,” and said the average home went pending in about two weeks.

Fewer homes sold this October than last, 19 against 27. Fewer sales that happen faster, with prices up 10%, usually means there weren’t enough houses for the buyers who wanted them.

Over the past twelve months, the median sale price Redfin reported ranged from about $188K to $270K, with 16 to 31 sales a month. It’s a small town, so use the range as a guide and the actual sales near a house as the real answer.

For Buyers

Old Forge prices are still within reach for a lot of first-time buyers. But you’ll be competing. Get fully preapproved before you start looking, know your top number before you walk in, and be ready to move the same day you see something you like. If you’re new to the process, my first-time home buyer guide walks through each step in order.

For Sellers

If you’ve been thinking about selling, the numbers are on your side. Buyers are paying full price and more for homes that show well. That said, Old Forge buyers know what the house down the street sold for. A clean, honest list price usually brings more offers than a high one.

Is Old Forge a Good Place to Live?

Old Forge is small and close-knit, and it’s proud of two things in particular: its pizza and its football team.

What People Like

The pizza. Old Forge pizza has its own rules. It’s baked in a rectangular metal pan. You order a tray, not a pie, and it comes in cuts, not slices. Most places make two kinds:

  • Red: a regular crust with tomato sauce and cheese
  • White: usually double-crusted, no sauce, lots of cheese and rosemary on top

Everybody here has a favorite. A few names you’ll hear: Arcaro & Genell, Revello’s and Anthony’s. Try more than one. That’s half the fun of living here.

Its Own School District

Old Forge has a district all to itself (more below), with an elementary school and a junior-senior high school right in town. The Blue Devils’ football rivalry with Riverside, the district next door, is one of the fiercest in the Lackawanna Football Conference.

Location

Old Forge sits between Scranton and Pittston. Taylor is next door, Moosic is across the river, and Interstate 81 and the Turnpike’s Northeast Extension are both a short drive away.

Prices

At about $222K, Old Forge sat just above Scranton’s median and about $150K below Moosic’s, a few minutes away.

What to Weigh

Competition

Good houses go fast. If you need a long time to decide, this market will test you.

Older Homes

A lot of Old Forge’s housing is older. Have an inspector look closely at the heating system, roof, wiring and foundation, and ask about mine subsidence insurance, as you would anywhere in the valley.

It’s a Small Town

For big shopping, you’ll drive to Moosic, Dickson City or Wilkes-Barre. Most people don’t mind. Some do.

What Locals Call It

Most people just say Old Forge, and for a borough this size that covers it. What you will hear a lot is “Old Forge pizza” used as the name of a style as well as a place. If you’re moving from out of town and someone offers you “a cut of white,” say yes.

Schools in Old Forge

Old Forge is served by the Old Forge School District, which covers only Old Forge Borough (Lackawanna County’s school district listing). It runs two schools:

  • Old Forge Elementary School, on Melmore Street
  • Old Forge Junior-Senior High School, on Marion Street

One small district for one small town means both schools are right in town. I won’t rank schools for you. Look at the public numbers on Pennsylvania’s Future Ready PA Index, then visit and talk to parents.

Property Taxes in Old Forge

Lackawanna County reassessed every property for 2026. Assessed values went up for many owners and millage rates came way down, so tax figures on older listings are likely out of date.

Here’s what the county’s 2026 sheet shows for an Old Forge property:

Taxing body2026 millage
Lackawanna County (county, library and education)5.79
Old Forge Borough1.43
Old Forge School District9.80
Total17.02

That’s about $1,702 a year for every $100,000 of assessed value, before any homestead exclusion. That’s a little below Moosic and well below Scranton.

Source: Lackawanna County 2026 millage rates. For due dates and how the reassessment works, see Lackawanna County property taxes.

After you buy, apply for the homestead exclusion. If the house will be your main home, ask the Lackawanna County assessment office about Pennsylvania’s homestead exclusion, which lowers the school part of your tax bill. There’s a yearly application deadline, so take care of it soon after closing. And if you think your new 2026 assessment is too high, ask the county how and when to appeal.

Getting Around

Old Forge is a car town. Interstate 81 is a short drive east across the river, with Scranton to the north and Wilkes-Barre to the south. The Turnpike’s Northeast Extension is reachable through neighboring Taylor. For trips back to New Jersey or New York, people take I-81 north to I-380 and on to Interstate 80. The Wilkes-Barre/Scranton International Airport is just down the valley near Avoca.

When Old Forge Homes Sell Fastest

Redfin’s monthly numbers over the past year:

  • Even the slow months were strong for sellers. In January and February 2026, homes took 34 to 43 days to sell but still closed at about 102% of list on average.
  • April was the one soft month: 46 days on market and about 95% of list.
  • Summer and fall were quick. From July through October, homes sold in 10 to 16 days, at 101.5% to 102.2% of list.

In other words, there hasn’t been much of an off-season in Old Forge lately. For a seller, almost any month in the past year would have worked. For a buyer, a soft stretch like last April doesn’t come along often, so be ready when one does.

What Your Budget Buys in Old Forge

Redfin put Old Forge’s median sale price per square foot at $130 in the three months through October 2026, up 6.6% from a year earlier. Roughly, $100,000 buys about 770 square feet at that rate, and $222,000, the median, about 1,700. Next door in Taylor, the rate was $93, so on paper the same money buys about 40% more space there. That’s the choice: Old Forge’s own school district and quick market against Taylor’s bigger houses for the money.

Before You Make an Offer in Old Forge

  • Have your preapproval letter and proof of funds ready before you tour.
  • Decide your top number in advance. In a market where homes sell over asking, it keeps you from overreaching in the moment.
  • Keep your inspection. You can make a strong offer without waiving it. We’ll talk about how.
  • Get the 2026 tax bill, since the reassessment changed it.
  • Ask about mine subsidence insurance on older homes, as you would anywhere in the valley.

How an Offer Comes Together in a Fast Market

Because Old Forge homes have been selling above asking, here’s what I walk buyers through before we write an offer:

  • The appraisal gap. When you pay over asking, the lender’s appraisal may come in below your price. Decide ahead of time how much of that gap, if any, you could cover in cash.
  • Your inspection. You can keep it and still be competitive. A shorter inspection period often helps more than waiving it.
  • A clean offer. Sellers compare terms as well as price: your financing, your closing date and how few conditions you attach.
  • Your limit. Pick your top number before you see the house. It keeps a bidding situation from making the decision for you.

None of this is unique to Old Forge, but in a town where 42% of October’s sales went over asking, it’s the difference between winning a house and watching someone else move in.

Nearby Towns to Compare

  • Taylor, right next door, sold for a median of about $264K and was a slower, more negotiable market in October.
  • Moosic, across the river, had the highest median of my ten towns, about $372K.

Compare all ten on the communities page.

Selling a Home in Old Forge

This is a good market to sell in, and a well-prepared home can draw several offers in its first week. My job is to help you get the most out of that first week: the right price, the right photos and a listing that brings the right buyers through the door.

Before real estate, I spent about twenty years on local TV, then worked in real estate marketing and business development. I’ll pull the Old Forge sales that actually match your home and tell you what I’d do before listing.

Start here: What is my home worth?

Dave Kuharchik smiling outdoors beside a waterfall, wearing an eXp Realty shirt

Frequently Asked Questions

What do homes sell for in Old Forge, PA?

The median sale price was about $222K in the three months through October 2026, up 10.5% from a year earlier, according to Redfin. Homes spent about 13 days on the market in October and sold for about 101.5% of list price on average, with 42% selling above asking.

Is Old Forge, PA a good place to live?

Many people think so. It’s a close-knit borough with its own school district, quick access to I-81 and the Turnpike and the pizza it’s famous for. Homes sell fast, so buyers need to be ready, and much of the housing is older.

What is Old Forge pizza?

Old Forge pizza is baked in a rectangular pan and sold by the tray, cut into squares called cuts. Red pizza has a regular crust with sauce and cheese. White pizza is usually double-crusted with no sauce, plenty of cheese and rosemary. Old Forge is known as the Pizza Capital of the World.

What school district serves Old Forge?

The Old Forge School District, which serves only Old Forge Borough. It has two schools: Old Forge Elementary School and Old Forge Junior-Senior High School.

How much are property taxes in Old Forge?

On Lackawanna County’s 2026 millage sheet, an Old Forge property pays 17.02 mills: 5.79 to the county, 1.43 to the borough and 9.80 to the Old Forge School District. That’s about $1,702 a year per $100,000 of assessed value. The county reassessed every property for 2026.

Is Old Forge a good town for first-time buyers?

It can be. The median sale price was about $222K in the three months through October 2026 (Redfin), within reach for many first-time buyers. You’ll compete for good houses, so get fully preapproved first and know your top number before you tour.

Thinking About Old Forge?

Call or text me at (570) 905-4300, or send me a note. Buying or selling, I’ll tell you what’s actually happening on your street.